> For the complete documentation index, see [llms.txt](https://docs.lpp-minduniverse.org/llms.txt). Markdown versions of documentation pages are available by appending `.md` to page URLs; this page is available as [Markdown](https://docs.lpp-minduniverse.org/lingua-pactum-protocol-lpp-documentation/11.-public-proof-and-validation/11.8-public-evidence-matrix.md).

# 11.8 Public Evidence Matrix

Every important public claim should remain traceable across:

**Claim**\
↓\
**Specification Status**\
↓\
**Implementation Status**\
↓\
**Validation Status**\
↓\
**Public Evidence**\
↓\
**Disclosure Level**

The canonical disclosure levels remain:

**P0 — Public Normative**\
**P1 — Public Technical**\
**P2 — Controlled Technical**\
**P3 — Confidential / Secret**

### Current High-Level Evidence Matrix

| Public Claim                                   | Current Evidence State                                                                     | Current Public Evidence                       | Disclosure    |
| ---------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | --------------------------------------------- | ------------- |
| Layer 0 Constitutional Admissibility           | Specified; partially implemented through MVP; not validated as complete protocol           | Papers / Protocol / GitBook                   | P0 / P1       |
| CP / EP separation                             | Specified; implemented; validated within current MVP scope                                 | Specifications + Public Proof v2.0            | P1            |
| No Permit → no governed execution              | Implemented; validated                                                                     | EX-02 + signed evidence                       | P1            |
| Signed Permit verification                     | Implemented; validated                                                                     | EX-04 + captured Permit / Artifact evidence   | P1            |
| Scope-bound execution                          | Implemented; validated                                                                     | EX-03                                         | P1            |
| Permit expiration enforcement                  | Implemented; core-verified                                                                 | Public Proof core verification                | P1            |
| Authority expiration / active-state validation | Implemented; core-verified / source-path supported                                         | Public Proof v2.0                             | P1            |
| Revoked authority blocks later execution       | Implemented; validated                                                                     | EX-06                                         | P1            |
| Replay rejection                               | Implemented; validated                                                                     | EX-05                                         | P1            |
| Execution-intent binding                       | Implemented; validated through current verifier/test paths                                 | Public Proof v2.0                             | P1            |
| Policy binding                                 | Implemented; validated through current verifier/test paths                                 | Public Proof v2.0                             | P1            |
| Admission Artifact generation                  | Implemented; demonstrated across disclosed scenario paths                                  | Signed Public Proof evidence                  | P1            |
| Artifact Verification / Audit Reconstruction   | Implemented for current MVP reconstruction checks; separately validated from six scenarios | Artifact Specification + Public Proof Track B | P1            |
| Public evidence-package consistency            | Validated                                                                                  | Public verifier: 113/113 PASS                 | P1            |
| DEFER decision path                            | Specified; not current MVP implementation claim                                            | Protocol / Research                           | P0 / P1       |
| COLLAPSE decision path                         | Specified; not current MVP implementation claim                                            | Protocol / Research                           | P0 / P1       |
| Continuous mid-execution admissibility         | Specified architecturally; not comprehensively validated                                   | Security / CP-EP specifications               | P1 / P2       |
| Distributed verification / multi-signer        | Research / technical direction; not current MVP validation                                 | Research / roadmap                            | P1 / P2       |
| Hardware-enforced anti-bypass                  | Higher-assurance deployment direction; not current MVP claim                               | Deployment architecture                       | P1 / P2       |
| Independent external reproduction              | Target state; not yet completed                                                            | Current status disclosure                     | Public status |

### Matrix Interpretation

The matrix must not be read as:

> One validated property\
> ⇒ Entire protocol validated

Validation remains property-specific.

For example:

> Replay rejection validated in EX-05

does not establish:

> universal distributed replay safety.

Likewise:

> 113/113 Public Evidence Verification

does not establish:

> complete private runtime reproduction.

The expanded evidence matrix is maintained again in Appendix 14.9.